
Research Article: Damania, R., Stringer, R., Karanth, K. U., & Stith, B. (2003). The economics of protecting tiger populations: Linking household behaviour to poaching and prey depletion. Land Economics, 79(2), 198–216.
Blog Author: Yashaswi Rao
Key highlights:
- Poaching and prey loss together threaten tigers.
- When livelihood opportunities are limited, the potential income from poaching can influence household decisions
- A marginal increase in the level of poaching can lead to population collapse of tigers, especially in the case of small populations.
- As human densities around wildlife reserves increase, there is greater pressure on the prey base of the forests, ultimately affecting tiger numbers.
- Better jobs, higher fines, and patrols make poaching less worthwhile.
Wild tigers are disappearing. Humans have destroyed over 90% of their habitat, and tigers now live in less than 5% of the forests that could potentially support them. This 2003 paper examines two urgent threats to tiger survival: poaching tigers for their body parts, and hunting of deer and wild pigs that tigers depend on for food. Unlike previous studies that focused primarily on tiger biology, this study presents an economic perspective to understand why people poach in the first place.
The researchers built a virtual model of a tiger reserve embedded within a mosaic of villages and agricultural fields based on forested landscapes of India. In the model, village households decide how to spend their time farming, working for wages, hunting prey for food, or poaching tigers. They make these choices weighing benefits against the risk of fines. This economic model was then matched with a biological model of tiger births, deaths, and availability of prey to examine how villager choices could impact tiger populations.
A few facts are important to understand the model. A tiger needs about 50 large prey animals a year, and a reserve needs around 500 prey animals per tiger. The illegal tiger trade is largely controlled by criminal gangs which retain most of the profits, while local poachers receive very little. With few convictions, people may also feel that they are unlikely to get caught or punished for poaching.
The model highlighted how small tiger populations were especially vulnerable. With plenty of prey, tigers could survive low levels of poaching. However, even a small increase in the price paid to poachers was enough to drive a small tiger population to extinction within 50 years. This suggested that small populations can collapse suddenly once poaching pressures push them past a critical threshold.
The number of people living near a reserve was found to be a major threat. More households led to increased hunting of prey, leaving tigers hungry. The model showed that a 50% rise in the number of households led to local extinction of tigers in under 60 years. Third, when prey is already scarce, even slightly more poaching can be deadly, so controlling poaching matters most under such a situation.
The model also explored whether improving economic opportunities and increasing the risks associated with poaching could help protect tigers.. It found that higher wages from alternative sources, larger fines, and a higher chance of being caught all reduced the incentive to poach. Additionally, doubling both wages and fines simultaneously was particularly effective, allowing the recovery of tiger populations in the model. This matches real life scenarios where reserves with effective patrolling, like Kanha and Kaziranga, still have tigers, while easily accessed, poorly protected forests often have none.
The authors suggest careful consideration when encouraging communities to use forest resources (especially close to tiger habitats) as unsustainable use of forest resources may lead to forest degradation, prey losses and declines in tiger populations. They also note that breeding tigers in captivity to lower prices might increase poaching, while doing nothing to address the loss of wild prey. Finally, The model’s findings should be taken with a pinch of salt, as reliable data on poaching, household activities and wildlife populations are limited. The authors chose a conservation approach and so, the real danger may be worse when factors like roads, minings, and construction of dams are added to the mix!
Overall, protecting tigers requires the protection of their prey as well, while giving local communities better economic options than hunting for subsistence or poaching wild tigers!
To access the original article, click here
Keywords: Tiger conservation, Poaching economics, Prey depletion, Rural poverty, Population collapse, Human-wildlife conflict

